Electric vs. Gas Fireplace: What’s Right for You?

Does your wood-burning fireplace often sit unused because of the time investment of building and maintaining a fire? Are you considering an upgrade to boost energy efficiency or to redesign the look and feel of the room? Or maybe you’re in the market for a new heating appliance, and are wondering which type of fuel will serve you best.

While the craving for warmth is as old as humanity itself, fireplace technology continues to change with the times. For instance, the push toward electrification for its economic and environmental impact has opened the market for impressive electric models that put the heat output and stylistic options of older models to shame.

If you’ve been weighing the benefits of gas and electric heating, be assured that both are compelling options that can add beauty, ease, and comfort to your home – and sustainability, too. With their distinct advantages, you’re free to explore which would fit best into your lifestyle and situation knowing that both are strong choices.

original infographic answering the question "what is electrification"

What Is Electrification?

As homeowners increasingly prioritize sustainability, many are considering a move away from fossil fuels towards electric solutions. This trend is called electrification, and it’s motivated by a desire to reduce carbon footprints and explore renewable energy sources.

Since electric fireplaces align with the wave of electrification, manufacturers are increasingly designing models with eco-conscious features. Another cool change in heating? Fireplaces are becoming more integrated into automated home systems, allowing homeowners to control their fireplace’s operation more efficiently – and conveniently.

It’s a good time to be a fireplace lover!

Gas vs. Electric…Which Is Better?

Let’s consider the pros and cons:

Electric Fireplaces

Pros:

  • Ease of use. This is basically unmatched in electric fireplaces. Plug your into an electrical outlet, push a button, and you’re in business. No venting, instant ambiance. This also makes electric fireplaces a prime option for renters.
  • Low maintenance. With electric, you aren’t scooping ash or maintaining a chimney – in fact, there’s very little maintenance involved.
  • Safety. With no gases to vent and no live flame, electric fireplaces and inserts pose little hazard. They also operate at lower temperatures.
  • Energy efficiency. All electricity used to operate an electric fireplace is converted directly into heat. Plus, adjustable settings give you control over heat output.
  • Environmental friendliness. Electric fireplaces don’t burn fossil fuels, and no emissions are generated within your home.

Cons:

  • Heat output. Electrical is a nice heat source, but an electric fireplace usually isn’t the best option for heating large spaces. They are great for smaller rooms or as a supplemental heat source, however.
  • Energy dependence. Electric fireplaces are firmly situated on the grid, so if you have concerns about interruptions to electrical service, an electric fireplace won’t be able to help you out there.
  • Flames. You aren’t getting the real thing here. But it’s worth checking out how far the effects have come – LEDs can’t entirely mimic a fire, but they can give you a nice, enticing glow.

Gas Fireplaces

Pros:

  • Flame appearance. Gas fireplaces feature natural flames that more closely resemble a wood-fueled fire – and the flames are often adjustable and anchored in realistic-looking decorative logs to model the ambiance of a wood fire (without the hassle).
  • Heat output and efficiency. You’re going to get substantial heat output from a gas fireplace. This grants the ability to heat larger spaces and rely more heavily on your fireplace as a primary heat source. Plus, it’s much more efficient than a traditional, open fireplace.
  • Heat control. Adjust the temp and flame height from the comfort of the couch? Yes, please. Gas can make that happen.
  • Independence. Most models will be able to continue to work and provide heat during electrical outages.
  • Relative environmental friendliness. Gas fireplaces are cleaner than wood-burning ones, with higher efficiency and fewer emissions produced.

Cons: 

  • Installation. Gas fireplaces will be a bit more involved to have installed than electric ones, and therefore (most likely) more costly as well. You need to have a gas line, venting systems, and all safety measures in place.
  • Maintenance. Gas will require more maintenance than electric, but far less than wood burning units.
  • Carbon emissions. It might sound like a skipping record, but as with maintenance… gas will produce more carbon emissions than electric, but fewer than wood burning units. The environmental impact’s much lower than that of burning wood, but it isn’t entirely carbon-free.

So, Which Is Best: Electric or Gas?

What’s true of the options available decades ago isn’t exactly the same today – and that’s a good thing! The possibilities in terms of efficiency, features, aesthetics, and overall design have expanded. While that’s good for consumers, it also leaves them more to navigate. 

So, what’s best? This decision depends on you! What are your needs and priorities? Are you after a less-involved installation process? Greater heat output? What’s the style and feel you’re trying to achieve? As you can see, gas and electric both have a great deal to offer. It’s just a matter of finding what’s the best fit for you.

Work With Lords Chimney Today

Whatever you choose, now is a great time to upgrade or bring the warmth and ambiance of a fireplace into your home for the first time. And if you still have lingering questions, there’s no pressure to make the decision today. Explore your options, consider your needs, and talk to our friendly pros to learn more about the possibilities for your space.

Call or schedule with us online today.

Can I Convert a Manufactured Fireplace to a Gas Log Set?

Quick answer to the question posed above? Yes! In fact, we’ve done just this.

Learn more below, then give us a call or reach out online with questions.

Manufactured Fireplace to Gas Log Set Conversion

original infographic featuring photos of a gas conversion for fireplace services

In this instance, we took a 20-25 year old manufactured metal fireplace and successfully upgraded it to a great-looking gas log fireplace. This included:

  • replacing the worn out and cracked panels
  • adding a new gas log set
  • ensuring everything was functioning correctly
  • matching new panels to meet the customer’s vision

What Are the Benefits of Gas-Fueled Fireplaces?

So why are so many, like this customer, making the switch to gas fireplaces?

  • They’re easy to operate. With the simple flip of a switch or the press of a button, gas fireplaces ignite instantly, providing immediate warmth and ambiance.
  • They require less fuel maintenance. Unlike wood-burning fireplaces, gas fireplaces do not require you to chop, store, or haul wood.
  • You can control them with a remote. Many models come with remote controls, allowing you to adjust the flame, heat output, and even set timers – all from the comfort of your couch.
  • They’re less messy. Gas fireplaces burn cleanly, producing no ash or soot, which means less mess and easier maintenance.
  • They’re highly efficient. Gas fireplaces can convert a higher percentage of fuel into usable heat compared to wood-burning models, leading to better overall efficiency and heat output.
  • They produce a controlled flame. The flame in a gas fireplace is controlled and contained, reducing the risk of sparks or embers causing a fire.
  • Most have safety features. Many gas fireplaces are equipped with safety features such as automatic shut-off if the pilot light goes out or if the unit overheats.
  • They come in a variety of styles. Gas fireplaces come in a wide range of styles and designs, from traditional to contemporary, allowing you to find one that fits your home’s decor, no problem.
  • They look realistic. Modern gas fireplaces often feature realistic flames and logs, providing the look and feel of a traditional wood fire – without the hassle.
  • They provide reliable, consistent heat. Gas fireplaces provide consistent heat output, which can be adjusted easily to maintain your desired comfort level.

Can Fireplace Refractory Panels Be Replaced?

Definitely! In fact, fireplace refractory panels are an essential component of a fireplace – designed to withstand high temperatures and protect the firebox from heat damage – so if you notice any damage, getting them replaced is highly encouraged.

What are signs refractory panels need replacing?

  • Cracks & Chips: Small cracks can often be repaired, but larger cracks or missing pieces indicate the need for replacement.
  • Warping or Bowing: Panels that have warped or bowed due to heat stress need to be replaced to ensure proper protection and efficiency.
  • Surface Erosion: If the surface of the panels is eroding, they will not provide adequate protection and should be replaced.

In these cases, be sure to call us in, so that we can complete a thorough inspection to determine the full extent of your damage. We’ll then take accurate measurements of the existing area, carefully remove the damaged panels, then install new and improved ones in their place.

All in all, refectory panel replacement isn’t a service to put off. Intact panels are crucial for protecting the firebox and surrounding structures from excessive heat (thus reducing the risk of fire hazards), and they help to maintain the fireplace’s efficiency by reflecting heat back into the room and ensuring proper airflow.

Is DIY refractory panel replacement an option?

This isn’t something we would ever recommend. In fact, DIY-ing any fireplace or chimney project comes with significant risks. Remember that these systems are designed for containing flames and keeping noxious gases from entering your home. Even a small mistake or slip-up can lead to bigger issues that put your household at risk – or, at the minimum, cause further damage that costs you significant dollars down the line.

Hiring a professional ensures that the panels are installed correctly and safely. We have the necessary tools, experience, and knowledge to handle the replacement efficiently.

Looking To Convert Your Fireplace? We Can Help

Converting any fireplace – whether it’s a manufactured fireplace to a gas log set or something else – is typically a feasible and beneficial option for many homeowners…and it’s one we’re happy to help you with.

Whether you’re looking to reduce your environmental footprint, simplify your home heating, or update the look of your living space, we have excellent solutions that can bring your vision and goals to life. Consult with our experts to assess your specific fireplace and ensure a safe, efficient conversion that meets all necessary codes and standards.

We can’t wait to hear from you – reach out now.

Maintaining A Gas Fireplace

There’s no doubt that gas fireplaces are the ideal pick for someone with a busy lifestyle. They are extremely easy to use, they produce a lot of heat, and they don’t require much cleanup. All you do is flip a switch, and you’ve got yourself a cozy place to relax at the end of the day!

Many assume that because gas fireplaces burn cleaner and require less upkeep, they don’t need as much professional attention as their wood-burning counterparts. This is not the case! Gas fireplaces need regular check-ups, too. They also need to be cleaned and swept from time to time, too.

Learn more about why these steps are so important in keeping your household safer, warmer, and more comfortable year after year by reading below. Then, call on us for advice, answers, and unbeatable customer service! At Lords Chimney, we’ve got your back!

Benefits Of Professional Care

By investing in regular professional care, you guarantee the best results from your gas fireplace. For one thing, you’ll avoid excess build-up. Just because you aren’t burning wood, doesn’t mean debris doesn’t accumulate, and it needs to be cleaned out on a regular basis to ensure things run smoothly. Putting this maintenance off will result in clogs and deterioration, both of which trigger poor air flow and gas leaks.

When you get an expert’s eye on the job, they can also spot any necessary repairs. If cracks and holes are present, you’re much more likely to come into contact with some toxic fumes, such as carbon monoxide. This gas is nearly impossible to detect, and it can be fatal if not treated right away. Lower your risk of exposure by having a professional inspect your system on a regular basis, and be sure to install carbon monoxide detectors throughout your home, too!

With the help of a pro, you can ensure safer and more efficient functioning with every passing season. It’s an investment you’ll be glad you made and, trust us when we say, that it’s the right move for saving money down the line. It’s always better to pay for affordable fixes sooner, rather than intricate and expensive ones later. You’ll save time, money, and a whole lot of stress! Call us in right away.

Schedule An Inspection

So, what’s one way of ensuring things run smoothly year after year? Schedule an annual inspection! Most homeowners use their fireplace a lot more near the end of the year, when the holiday season is in full swing, so schedule an inspection sometime before your burning period begins each year to guarantee optimal efficiency.

At Lords Chimney, our CSIA certified team has everything necessary to get the job done right! Count on us to for all your chimney and fireplace care. Our team won’t let you down!

Gas Appliance Barrier Screens

Direct vent gas fireplaces have grown in popularity in recent years. With more realistic looking flames, a multitude of style options, and incredible ease of use, gas fireplaces allow families to enjoy the ambiance and warmth of a fire without the hassle and work associated with wood.

While gas fireplaces are more convenient and easy to use, they still have safety risks associated with them. A primary concern with gas fireplaces – especially in families with young children or pets – is the risk of burns associated with the hot glass fronts of the fireplace units.

gas-appliance-barrier-screens-image-houston-tx-lords-chimney

New fireplace safety standards

Beginning on January 1, 2015, all newly manufactured gas fireplaces and stoves with glass fronts will be required to include an installed protective barrier. This will apply to all appliances that have a glass surface temperature of 172 degrees or higher when in use.

“While gas fireplaces, stoves and inserts are a great asset to any home, the glass can become very hot during operation and stay hot long afterwards, creating a potential burn hazard,” said Hearth, Patio, and Barbeque Association president Jack Goldman. “In the past several years, there have been reports of burns involving young children and others who may not been aware of the potential risk of touching the hot glass on gas fireplaces, inserts and stoves. While we believe these incidents are few, even one is too many. We believe the new safety standard will provide greater protection to young children and others with special needs.”

This new standard was originally approved in 2012 by the American National Standards Institute. The U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission worked with the fireplace and hearth industry to implement the standard in an effort to protect families from accidental burns. The standard will apply to all units manufactured after January 1, 2015. Retailers may continue to sell units manufactured before this date that do not meet the new safety standards.

Safety tips for families

If you have an existing gas appliance, there are a number of things you can do to protect yourself and your family from accidental burns. These common sense safety tips can help keep everyone in your home safe.

  • Don’t leave children or pets unattended in front of a fireplace that is in use or has been turned off
  • Teach children about fireplace safety and to never touch the glass of the fireplace
  • Keep the remote control of the fireplace out of reach to prevent it from being accidentally turned on
  • Install a switch lock to prevent children from turning on any gas appliances

Additional safety products

There are a number of safety products available to homeowners who already own gas appliances. Protective barriers or screens are the easiest and most common safety precaution. Safety screens come in a variety of styles and can be attached directly to the front of the fireplace or left as freestanding screens. Likewise, baby gates or barriers can be used to keep children and pets away from the fireplace when it is in use.

When installing aftermarket screens directly to the front of your hearth, please be aware that they may change the functionality of your fireplace. Check with a fireplace professional before installing something directly to the fireplace.

If you have questions about making your gas appliance safer, contact Lord’s Chimney today. Our expert staff is highly trained and ready to make sure you can enjoy your gas fireplace while keeping your family safe.